You can keep it in your pants
Apr. 7th, 2011 04:42 pmEvery so often, usually in a discussion of sex education or sexual health services for teenagers, I hear someone come out with something like "Abstinence isn't always feasible" or "we need to be realistic: not everyone can control their underwear". Obviously, the fact that some teenagers will be involved in sexual acts which they have no control over is trivially true because some teenagers get raped, but I don't think that that is what people are referring to when they say these things. Usually these kinds of views are expressed by Good American Liberals as part of an explanation of why abstinence only education doesn't work. I wonder where this idea comes from. I've never felt that I didn't have control over my sexual behaviour. Maybe in retrospect I'll think "Knowing what I know now that wasn't the best thing to do", but I think I've always done what I felt was the best thing to do in the situation at the time. I guess it comes from a hideous compromise. We know that most teenagers have sex, even if you hand out tacky jewellery in return for them promising not to. However, in the popular consciousness teenage sex is still viewed as a Problem. So people say "Obviously I don't approve of teenagers having sex but it's going to happen no matter what we do we better give them condoms." These conversations seem to treat teenage sex like a unpreventable natural disaster.
I think that there are three things which people don't want to acknowledge when they claim that teenagers can't control their sexual behaviour.
1) Some teenagers engage in sexual acts because they enjoy them and the benefits of them outweigh the risks of them in their judgement. Sometimes it's easier all around to frame teenagers as helpless victims of their libidos than people who just don't want to do what you want them to do. I think people also like avoiding this idea because if teenagers are in some way rational rather than automatons driven entirely by lust, then you'd have to admit that, yes, providing access to contraceptives may tip the balance for some teenagers from not having sex into having sex or from engaging only in less risky sexual acts into coitus. That behavioural switch is going to be hugely outweighed by the decrease in sexual infections and unplanned pregnancies, but if you care more about whether teens have sex than the consequences, it does make sense to keep them away from condoms.
2) Some teenagers are engaging in unfulfilling and/or unwise sexual behaviour because they live in a culture which tells them that to be happy/successful/of any value as a human being you have to be rubbing your genitals against someone else's. However, I'm not holding my breath for the day that people realise that if you don't want teens to fuck each other, maybe not raising them diet of films in which the female characters' happy ending is to be sexy and submissive enough to get a man's attention would be more effective than not letting them buy the morning after pill.
3) Some teenagers are raped. Often by other teens. In fact, several studies have found that abuse, including sexual abuse, is more common in teenage relationships than in older age groups.
Point 3 brings me around to why I really hate people claiming that teenagers have no control of their sexual behaviour: it contributes to rape culture. If you spread the idea that people can't control their sexual behaviour, it promotes the idea that maybe it wasn't the perpetrator's fault that he raped someone. And if it wasn't his fault maybe it was his victim's because she excited his uncontrollable lusts. Our society is already more than willing to find any excuse to excuse poor ickle rapists and blame their victims. Let's not add to it. Teenagers have sex because they want to or because they are coerced or forced by someone else who wants to. They don't trip and end up with their genitals inside each other.
I think that there are three things which people don't want to acknowledge when they claim that teenagers can't control their sexual behaviour.
1) Some teenagers engage in sexual acts because they enjoy them and the benefits of them outweigh the risks of them in their judgement. Sometimes it's easier all around to frame teenagers as helpless victims of their libidos than people who just don't want to do what you want them to do. I think people also like avoiding this idea because if teenagers are in some way rational rather than automatons driven entirely by lust, then you'd have to admit that, yes, providing access to contraceptives may tip the balance for some teenagers from not having sex into having sex or from engaging only in less risky sexual acts into coitus. That behavioural switch is going to be hugely outweighed by the decrease in sexual infections and unplanned pregnancies, but if you care more about whether teens have sex than the consequences, it does make sense to keep them away from condoms.
2) Some teenagers are engaging in unfulfilling and/or unwise sexual behaviour because they live in a culture which tells them that to be happy/successful/of any value as a human being you have to be rubbing your genitals against someone else's. However, I'm not holding my breath for the day that people realise that if you don't want teens to fuck each other, maybe not raising them diet of films in which the female characters' happy ending is to be sexy and submissive enough to get a man's attention would be more effective than not letting them buy the morning after pill.
3) Some teenagers are raped. Often by other teens. In fact, several studies have found that abuse, including sexual abuse, is more common in teenage relationships than in older age groups.
Point 3 brings me around to why I really hate people claiming that teenagers have no control of their sexual behaviour: it contributes to rape culture. If you spread the idea that people can't control their sexual behaviour, it promotes the idea that maybe it wasn't the perpetrator's fault that he raped someone. And if it wasn't his fault maybe it was his victim's because she excited his uncontrollable lusts. Our society is already more than willing to find any excuse to excuse poor ickle rapists and blame their victims. Let's not add to it. Teenagers have sex because they want to or because they are coerced or forced by someone else who wants to. They don't trip and end up with their genitals inside each other.